Everything is not what it seems…

Go Set a Watchman Parts III and IV

I just finished the next few chapters of the novel GSAW and man was it heavy… Not much plot development occurs, but it is definitely the section with the most character development so far.


Image result for not again meme


As I explained in my earlier post, I was very shocked to find out about the racism present in Maycomb. Unfortunately, it gets worse. After cleaning up the living room, Jean finds Atticus’ copy of the The Black Plague: a book describing the inferiority  of blacks to white and the importance of controlling them “for their own good”. And let me tell you, Jean is as astonished as I am. She makes a connection of the pamphlet to Atticus and Hank’s strange Sunday meetings and makes a point of finding out what is going on. Her thoughts after finding this pamphlet lead believe me to think that Atticus and Hank are connected to the Klu Klux Klan. It was mentioned once before but in this chapter, Jean refers to them as the

“Invisible Empire, who hated Catholics; ignorant, fear-ridden, red-faced, boorish, law-abiding […] trash.” (Lee, 104)

Now in the early chapters, I had come to the conclusion that Jean herself had grown out of her innocent phase and had abided to the racist, bigoted surrounding her. However, it was her father, the man who was seen as a hero in TKAM for making deep efforts to save an innocent black man against a rape case, who stood as a member of a racist committee. At this point, Jean and I both couldn’t believe what was happening. And luckily for the both of us, Jean decided to go check herself. When she arrives, she describes the scene like so:

“Below her, on rough benches, sat not only most of the trash in Maycomb County, but the country’s most respectable men. She looked toward the far end of the room [..] at a long table, sat her father, Henry Clinton.” (105)

Image result for racist atticusAnd with that sentence, my thoughts were confirmed. Atticus hadn’t just gotten a pamphlet in the mail and forgot to throw it out, he had really believed in it. This news hits Jean so hard that she eventually throws up (chill). The next morning,  she tries to pause her anger to help her father when he explains that he will be taking a black man’s murder case. Faith in humanity restored? Think again. Atticus does not do so out of the goodness of his own heart, but mainly to stop colored lawyers from infiltrating Maycomb. He doesn’t even try to win the case and explains that he will help the black guy plead guilty.

These chapters have been very eye-opening for Jean and I. Dark secrets are revealed about her father and her soon-to-be husband (probably not anymore?). Fortunately, Jean has left some hope in me. She describes herself as being “color-blind” (122) meaning that she, unlike the others, didn’t believe in racism. Hooray! Sorry for doubting you Scout! I hope her stubbornness and willingness lead me to keep some kind of hope that she may be able to change her father and Hank’s opinions.


Some things never change…or do they?

This reading has also opened more events to discuss norms and expectations. To begin with, as Jean is exposed to new truths on her father, she reminiscences over the good actions of his past

“he won an acquittal for a colored boy on a rape charge. The chief witness for the prosecution was a white girl.” (109)

Image result for tkam atticusNice try Jean, but your father never actually won the case. He lost and Tom’s death soon followed, don’t you remember running out of the courthouse that and crying over the verdict? It seems as although everyone around her changed, Jean refuses to do so. She is still the innocent Scout she was in the first novel and refuses to accept that any harm could be done in her universe. Sorry, pal, but life doesn’t work like that.

Furthermore, Jean later discusses of the expectations that were set for her even though the news she was bearing made her despise her father, to an extent. Jean would “sit out her two weeks home in polite detachment, saying nothing, asking nothing, blaming not. She would do as well as could be expected under the circumstances” (142). Knowing Jean’s character, it is obvious that the first thing she wants to do is call out Atticus and ask what the hell is wrong with him. Buuuuuuuuut it didn’t work like that in her day and age, especially with concerns over subjects as touchy as race. Jean understands what is expected of her in this situation, and changes her manners from the stubborn usual self. We know this must really be a big deal when Jean thinks this should be handled a different way. This quote can adobe analyzed under a feminist lens, as it portrays Jean submission to an aspect of domesticity. It is the belief of domesticity that governs the thought that woman must stay at home (in their place) and not be heard. Jean is conforming by accepting that although she is angry, she must stay quiet because that is how she is supposed to act. In this chapter, we also see Jean cleaning the house, attempting to mow the lawn, etc. furthering that she believes she should stay at home.  

The final chapter of this section deal with Jean’s expectations of her surroundings. Growing up “color blind”, not ever noticing racism as a pressing issue in her hometown, and moving away to a more open-minded environment in her later years all attributed to Jean’s “advanced” way of thinking. Since she had never paid much attention to news on this topic, she had always been shielded from it’s horror, thus seeing Maycomb in a different light. To her, it was home. It was where the people she loved resided. But by being unable to see the town and it’s people for who they really are, Jean disappoints herself in setting expectations that are much too unrealistic.

“Now she was aware of a sharp apartness, a separation, not from Atticus and Henry merely. All of Maycomb and Maycomb County were leaving her as the hours passed, and she automatically blamed herself.” (154)

She is slowly detaching herself from her roots after realizing that she does not belong there anymore. I really hope that she can help Atticus and Henry in the next few chapters.


Jean? or Jesus?

As you know, the title of the novel is Go Set a Watchman. Therefore, any mentions of the title in the novel must be important, right? Right. The title is mentioned for the first time in a religious environment, and we find out that the title comes from a bible verse:

“For thus hath the Lord said unto me,

Go, set a watchman, let him declare what he seeth” (95)

Image result for jesusSome people might not think too much of it, but I believe that the environment in which the title is brought up tells us a lot about what the novel itself is about. In this verse, a watchman is literally just that; a watchman. He is sent to get information about what he sees to tell the Lord. Just like Simon was in Lord of the Flies, Jean must represent some kind of god-like figure. From the beginning, she is set apart from the other characters as the only one with “just” morals reflecting ideas of equality for all (something Jesus obviously wanted for us all). I believe that she was sent to Maycomb to witness the tragedies that racism have helped unfold and her purpose is to bring light to her community to make them understand racial equality.


Like mother like…son

I’m not sure what this will contribute to later on, but it is interesting to note that we finally find out the reason behind Jem’s death. Just like his mother, Jem had a terribly weak heart and passed away due to a heart attack. At the rate that Jean is finding things out, will the she horrified into cardiac arrest?


Anyways, that’s all for me for this week guys. Let me know in the comment section below what you think will happen to Jean! Will she try to change Atticus’ mind about this? Or will she completely just shun her family away?


Works Cited


5 thoughts on “Everything is not what it seems…

  1. I love the use of the pictures, funny! I’m glad that Jean admits that she is colour blind and everything in the town is corrupt. Seeing Jean act as a domestic girl was so weird because she is such a curious and confident child. It is interesting that you think Jean is “portrayed” as god like figure because one of the worst excuse is, “we’ve always done it this way”. Do you think Jean will try to change the town or accept the brutal truth and stay quiet about it.


    1. Thank you! And to be honest, I think she will speak up about the issues going on in her town but I don’t think much will happen. Just like the civil rights movement was ongoing for ever a decade, I believe that it would take much longer for the town of maycomb simply because all the present generations are already hard-wired. It was easy for Jean to grow up so open minded because she lived in NYC after, a city who is known for its diversity. However for maycomb, everyone grows up with the same small town mentality ( you can see it in Hank’s opinions) so they’d need to start by educating the next generation (jean’s kids). What do you think?


      Liked by 1 person

  2. Hey LL,

    First I’d like to say, I love that little comic of Scout and Atticus (Fox news being put on blast).I agree that the plot has gotten deeper, but hasn’t really developed further than the “girl realizes life isn’t sunshine and rainbows”. Jean Louise as a character though… the transition from Scout to Jean Louise cannot be more blatant. I’m really surprised she didn’t storm in there and demand answers, but I guess she’s learned to be subtle over the last 17-ish years. Who knows though, humans are creatures of habit.
    I’m going to throw it back to the Lord of the Flies days, do you believe people are inherently evil/bad, or is it a learned behaviour? (I know it’s a tough question) I think for the most part, someone’s behaviour is a consequence of their surroundings, but there are some cases where someone’s upbringing would in no way affect them negatively to turn down the wrong path. So I guess what I’m trying to say is, there is inherent evil.

    I think Jean Louise will 100% confront Atticus about this, but will she take a heated approach or a more subtle one? Harper Lee can only tell us.



    1. Thank you Jess! I’m glad you brought up Lord of The Flies, because I see many parallels between. To be honest, part of me wants to think that evil/bad is a learned behaviour but just like in the Lord of the Flies, this novel is proving otherwise. Everyone’s true Colors are show and I believe that that’s the way they have always been (ex: Atticus always being racist). The only reason some characters were depicted otherwise was due to To Kill a Mockingbird being written in Scout’s innocent point of view. Atticus might’ve been as racist back then, but being younger, she wanted to believe her dad was perfect and a hero and so she Invented another idealized version of him.

      Do you think the discrepancies in the novel are due to Harpee Lee’s carelessness as GSAW was never supposed to be published so she changed the storyline in TKAM, or was it on purpose to show Scout’s character development over the years?


      Liked by 1 person

      1. LL,
        I think we can parallel Scout to Gatsby too. They both want to live in the past, where their visions of their perfect person holds true. I think everyone has gone through that, we always deny things that change our views on life.

        I don’t think the discrepancy between GSaW and TKaM was intentional; if it was, I feel like the Tom verdict would have been reversed just to ruin our lives even more. I think the change came from GSaW being written first. It’s likely that Harper Lee initially wanted Tom to have a happy ending, but then decided against it when she wrote TKaM, and never had the chance to go back and change it in GSaW.


        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s